I'd like to start this off by noting that both Jennifer Aniston and Vince Vaughn's people deny they are engaged-like I said, I keep hearing that they aren't a real couple. 1) Battlestar Galactica. This is the best show on TV right now (okay, it isn't on right now, not even in reruns, but you can watch all of last season on iTunes. And it starts again in October). I feel about Battlestar the way I felt about the X-Files during season two-that was a great show that no one else knew about. Battlestar takes on practically every major issue going on in the world right now and deals with it and subverts it, usually in the same episode and usually with more than one issue. The evil Cylon robots all believe in one God, one purpose. The humans are polytheistic-and squabble amongst themselves over who is who is truly religious and holy. The humans torture the robots-are they doing the right thing? The ARE robots, but they look human and act like humans-do they still deserve to be tortured? And what happens when it's the supposed good guys doing the torturing? Is it an action show? There is plenty of action, but each pilot has their own issues,from Apollo betraying his father the Commander by helping the President to escape (and thereby committing treason), to Starbuck the claiming she doesn't remember the name of anyone who has been killed under her command and ten minutes later naming all of the them while saluting the new ace who has displaced her. I can't say enough about this show and all the things it does in each episode-it's amazing. And just when you think they can't do anything new-they do it. Just watch the season finale of the 2nd season and tell me I'm wrong. Also, I'd like to give kudos to Mary McDonnell and Edward James Olmos-two actors who can show their emotions with the most subtle change of expression-they are amazing. 2) The Closer-the show sings because of Kyra Sedgewick. Without her, it would just be another somewhat better than average cop show, but due to her intelligent acting and the chemistry between the rest of the cast, it goes far above your average show. Now let's see if it can better...3) Fine. I love Project Runway. I don't know why I have to keep arguing that you can be a total science fiction nerd and still love clothes-but that argument never ends for me. Regardless, Project Runway is awesome. The catty, cutthroat contestants, the catty cutthroat judges, the fabulous (and less than fabulous) clothes...And Tim Gunn saying "I don't know what I'm looking at here" and "Make it work"...it's great. It's also the only reality show I watch, so I don't want any comments about American Idol or any other show, because I just don't care.4) Veronica Mars. This is a great show-why aren't you watching it? Kristen Bell's delivery can't be beat-she can go from humor to pathos and back in the same scene and take you along for the ride. And Enrico Colantoni and Jason Dohring as her father and ex-boyfriend (is he the boyfriend again?) are both wonderful smartasses. Actually, they all are and I can appreciate that in fictional characters.5) Supernatural. I used to watch CSI religiously when it first came on TV. I loved the Grissom opening wittiscms, Catherine's ongoing Daddy issues and how her daughter only showed up when it convenient, how Warrick and Nick would banter while Sara was off drinking...it was great (although I think it still hasn't quite lived up to the promise of the premiere, which was a truly great show). But somewhere after the Quentin Tarantino funfest that was the season finale awhile ago...I just couldn't do it anymore. I have a high tolerance for freaks and weirdos-I love freaks and weirdos-but it left a bad taste every time I watched. And so-Supernatural. It replaced the Night Stalker (not even 25% as good as the original but I still kind of liked it). But Supernatural has two guys working against the powers of Darkness (and one power in particular that's really bad) while trying find their father (and they found him and fought the bad guy-but are they dead? ) The season finale was killer and they got renewed-so I guess that means that they really aren't dead...Mulder died in so many episodes I can't keep count (actually I can but we won't go into that) so I guess other characters are allowed to do it too.6) Eureka. This show is on the verge of greatness. If, as Entertainment Weekly says, it acknowleges its X-File roots (I was heartened by its use of the word Consortium in the episode that aired on Agust 8th) then it will become a great. The premiere and one subsequent episode had a very jokey, ha-ha, isn't this funny and cute tone, with an underlying layer of darkness. The two levels did not work together very well-but thenext two episodes managed to a satisfying level of darkness. The episode where the brilliant female scientist had her ideas, thoughts and memories stolen from her by her not-so-brilliant huband and you don't know if she's going to let him be killed or not-it was very good. And the most recent one where a group had paranoid and violent tendencies put into the brainwaves when they accidentally got into the wrong weapons satellite was very well done. I have high hopes for this show-they may be dashed upon the rocks of mediocrity but the Sci-fi channel doesn't have much to lose so we'll see what happens. 7) Bones-I have a soft spot for Bones even though it is coasting on the charisma of its leads. The leads are Emily DeSchanel and David Boreaneaz and they are good looking and not entirely painful to watch. It's clear that Fox wants them to be Mulder and Scully (who they referenced in the first episode) and they never will be. If you want a show where nothing really bad will happen to any of the main characters (they may end up in the hospital but that's about it), this is your show. But they have nice chemistry together and the supporting cast is pretty good. 8) I feel I must put House in here just because I think any cranky and sarcastic character on TV (and not in a cute way) is somehow a shout-out to me. "Yes, we know you're out there watching this show" it seems to say to me. He's not likeable (okay, I don't think anyone has said I'm not likeable. There are people who don't like me but that's different. It just is.) but he is both smart and a smartass and he doesn't care what other people think. My sister once told me that cranky, mean and sarcastic was no way to go through life (I was 17 at the time and it was clear she didn't know me very well) and I think both I and Dr House prove her wrong. I don't know if that's good or bad and one of us isn't fictional but it's too late now.
9&10) The Daily Show and The Colbert Report-two of the funniest and sharpest shows on TV. You can't beat Jon Stewart for a clever insult or Stephen Colbert for playing the pompous idiot (The Word segment of Colbert is the best part of the show-when the show itself mocks him, it does so in a really smart way). You like politics viewed through the lens of snark, these are your shows.
And a few words about Lost...
I loved the first season of Lost. It was spooky and confusing and always interesting. Even the characters I didn't like, I liked because you can't like every character on a show-TV doesn't work that way. The acting was usually really good, even when the characters were annoying (I'm looking at you, Kate). I don't know quite how to read the second season. It had its moments-and when you call someone Anna Lucia (this didn't happen in MY office) because she's bitchy, then you know the show has entered into the collective unconscious. And this show actually made me tear up (not admitting if I actually cried or not) when Bernard and Rose found each other. And yet, it wasn't the same. Too many episodes repeated information we already had without adding any new nuances (although the episodes about the Tailies were masterful). There were too many episodes where the discussions didn't lead anywhere and did not give any new insight into the characters-was this to show they could have pointless discussions like real people? It confused and irritated me and not in a good way. We'll see what happens next season-I really liked the season two season finale so I'm still hoping they can redeem themselves.
Coming up...my essay on why I hated Miami Vice..in which a friend plays a prominent role!